| Year | Winner |
|---|---|
| 1972 | Army (1) |
| 1973 | Navy (1) |
| 1974 | Shared (Navy retained trophy) (1) |
| 1975 | Navy (2) |
| 1976 | Shared (Navy retained trophy) (2) |
| 1977 | Army (2) |
| 1978 | Navy (3) |
| 1979 | Navy (4) |
| 1980 | Shared (Navy retained trophy) (3) |
| 1981 | Navy (5) |
| 1982 | Air Force (1) |
| 1983 | Air Force (2) |
| 1984 | Army (3) |
| 1985 | Air Force (3) |
| 1986 | Army (4) |
| 1987 | Air Force (4) |
| 1988 | Army (5) |
| 1989 | Air Force (5) |
| 1990 | Air Force (6) |
| 1991 | Air Force (7) |
| 1992 | Air Force (8) |
| 1993 | Shared (Air Force retained trophy) (4) |
| 1994 | Air Force (9) |
| 1995 | Air Force (10) |
| 1996 | Army (6) |
| 1997 | Air Force (11) |
| 1998 | Air Force (12) |
| 1999 | Air Force (13) |
| 2000 | Air Force (14) |
| 2001 | Air Force (15) |
| 2002 | Air Force (16) |
| 2003 | Navy (6) |
| 2004 | Navy (7) |
| 2005 | Navy (8) |
| 2006 | Navy (9) |
| 2007 | Navy (10) |
| 2008 | Navy (11) |
| 2009 | Navy (12) |
| 2010 | Air Force (17) |
| 2011 | Air Force (18) |
| 2012 | Navy (13) |
| 2013 | Navy (14) |
| 2014 | Air Force (19) |
| 2015 | Navy (15) |
| 2016 | Air Force (20) |
| 2017 | Army (7) |
| 2018 | Army (8) |
| 2019 | Navy (16) |
| 2020 | Army (9) |
| 2021 | Shared (Army retained) |
| 2022 | Air Force (21) |
| 2023 | Army (10) |
CIC Trophy Wins by School: Air Force 21, Navy 16, Army 10.